We’ve got a problem with music theory

The Pianodao Guest Book
Interviews • Opinions • Guest Posts

Pianist, composer, and educator GARRETH BROOKE contributes this thoughtful, insightful, and provocative guest post, in which he challenges us to reconsider how we teach and learn music theory as pianists…


Actually, we’ve got many problems with music theory.

  • We are intimidated by it
  • We find it boring
  • We were taught it poorly
  • There are too few good resources out there
  • Our exam boards have warped our understanding of what it is
  • We often teach it merely so our students can progress to the next piano exam.

Thankfully it is not all bad news. There are good music theory teachers out there, just as there are musicians who have a profound understanding of theory, and there are increasing numbers of good teaching resources available. Sadly, though, they still represent a sizeable minority rather than what they should be: the overwhelming majority.

And the result of all these problems? We have lost sight of the purpose of music theory. Music theory exists to explain why music is beautiful.

Why does this chord sequence appeal to us so powerfully that it gives us spine-tingles, or makes us cry? Why does this rhythm make us want to move our bodies in a certain way?

Continue reading We’ve got a problem with music theory

Garreth Brooke • A Piano Journey

The Pianodao Guest Book
Interviews • Opinions • Guest Posts

GARRETH BROOKE is a British/German musician whose original music has been released on several labels and has received millions of streams. He has performed live all over Europe, and his compositions have been published by Breitkopf & Härtel, Faber Music, and Editions Musica Ferrum.

Garreth’s exclusive UK live date for 2026 will be his upcoming appearance at the Milton Keynes Piano Celebration:



In this moving and inspiring interview, we discuss how Garreth’s musical journey has been shaped by love, loss, healing, and the pathway that has ultimately led to his music touching listeners around the world…

Continue reading Garreth Brooke • A Piano Journey

Garreth Broke • Healing

Pianodao Music Library
Selected and Reviewed by Andrew Eales

Garreth Brooke is a talented English composer currently living and working in Germany. He has been publishing recordings of his music on Soundcloud, Bandcamp and elsewhere for several years, gaining an appreciative audience drawn to the new-classical style and emotive qualities of his writing and playing.

In this review, it’s my pleasure to review the most recent publication of Garreth’s music, appearing under his alias Garreth Broke: Healing and published by Editions Musica Ferrum.

Continue reading Garreth Broke • Healing