An upright piano in a warm welcoming room

The Piano Stool: a safe harbour

The Pianodao Guest Book
Interviews • Opinions • Guest Posts

In this new guest post for Pianodao, best-selling author KAREN MARSHALL points to the importance of helping students feel welcome, seen, and ready to learn…


Years ago, my late teacher Eric Leveridge told me,

“Karen, remember that a piano teacher can actually be providing a service to the community. Supporting parents and young people as they make their way in life.” 

I have never forgotten those words. Instrumental educators enjoy the rare privilege of spending years of consistent, one-to-one time with a child. Sometimes for up to twelve years, or more. We are not just teaching an instrument; we form part of that child’s long-term developmental support team. 

Attachment theory offers a helpful lens through which we can understand this connection. Borrowing John Bowlby’s concept of a “secure base”, we can see how music teachers can create a predictable, encouraging environment where children feel safe enough to take creative risks.

This is not to suggest we replace parents or act as therapists, but rather to recognise the meaningful difference a trusted, consistent adult can make. 

Many of us notice students arriving at lessons with limited attention, heightened anxiety, or low resilience. Modern stressors, disrupted routines, and educational pressures profoundly impact confidence. The piano stool can become a reassuring space, a place to rebuild resilience and rediscover potential. 

Demographic data indicates that many families face significant hardships. Figures from the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) show that up to a third of UK children live in relative poverty, while the Department for Education (DfE) tracks steady rates of looked-after children and those on child protection registers.

These realities inevitably enter our studios. Whether through school bursaries or quietly subsidised private lessons, we regularly encounter hidden struggles.

In my own piano teaching practice, I have taught children who have suffered the tragic loss of a parent. Being a stabilising adult in a young person’s life during periods of trauma is a real privilege.

The value of a calm, predictable presence is something I have encountered time and again in my work with young people. 

For some children, earlier developmental experiences affect how they respond to authority, making ordinary mistakes feel disproportionately threatening. In a busy classroom of thirty, they can easily mask fear with perfectionism, or act it out defensively. For some pupils, an adult mentor outside of school can offer an essential anchor of stability. 

At the same time, we must distinguish between relational attachment needs and neurological processing differences. While emotional trauma and neurodivergence can manifest in similar ways, such as sensory overload, executive dysfunction, or task avoidance, they stem from different sources and can benefit from distinct teaching strategies. 

Understanding neurodiversity is not about assuming emotional insecurity, but about adapting our teaching toolkits so that students with ADHD, dyslexia, dyspraxia, or autism can thrive. The focus is more likely to be on managing cognitive load, communication styles, and sensory preferences, so that our studios remain accessible and welcoming to all.

To support this, the Department for Education’s Special Educational Needs and Disability (SEND) Code of Practice outlines four broad areas of need that provide a useful framework for studio teachers: 

  • Communication and Interaction: covering speech, language, and communication needs alongside autism spectrum conditions
  • Cognition and Learning: encompassing general learning differences as well as specific difficulties like dyslexia, dyscalculia, and dyspraxia.
  • Social, Emotional, and Mental Health: addressing challenges with emotional regulation, heightened anxiety, and neurodevelopmental conditions such as ADHD.
  • Sensory and Physical Needs: incorporating visual or hearing impairments, physical disabilities, and sensory processing differences that require adaptive physical setups.

Keeping these categories in mind helps us tailor our environment to the specific underlying need rather than misinterpreting a child’s response as simple reluctance. 

Unlike a busy school environment, a one-to-one music studio lesson offers a degree of quiet predictability that is difficult to find elsewhere. Regular weekly lessons provide a dedicated slot of undivided attention, serving as a comforting ritual. 

Furthermore, our subject matter is inherently hands-on and sensory. Teaching a child to feel a steady pulse, breathe into a musical phrase, or feel the physical drop of weight into the keys gives a nervous pupil something concrete to focus on in the present moment. 

Adopting a flexible approach incorporating singing, rhythm work, and movement before notation hits the page, focusing on “sound before symbol“, prevents the material from overwhelming the pupil. We can also build ownership by personalising the music. We must constantly watch body language and ask:

“Is this material working right now, or do I need to adapt?”

If we want children to feel secure, we need to recognise the power dynamic of a private lesson.

To a young student, an adult sitting closely beside them in a small room can seem like a powerful figure. An exasperated sigh, a furrowed brow, or a sharp tone might seem minor to us, but a pupil looking for signs of failure can take them as clear disapproval.

Rita Pierson’s famous observation in her TED talk that children don’t learn well from people they don’t like remains a cornerstone of good practice. Simply smiling as the student enters the studio, and taking a genuine interest in their life lets them know you are firmly on their team.

If a student freezes or becomes overwhelmed, piling on verbal instructions can worsen the block. Instead, we can soften our posture, lean back to give them physical space, and break the task down into smaller, achievable steps. 

If a child is sensitive to making mistakes, a blunt correction like “That’s the wrong note, do it again!” can trigger a shutdown. Sometimes the most useful thing we can do first is help them regain their composure using a calm voice. 

Once settled, we can reframe the mistake with curiosity:

“What did you notice in your playing?”

It is always better if they identify a mistake rather than us pointing it out. We can become detectives together about why it happened. If notation is particularly busy, isolating a single bar with a cut-out paper window removes visual overwhelm. 

The mistake is no longer something to be ashamed of; it is simply something we explore together. By prioritising connection before correction, we create safety.

A child who feels safe feels permitted to make mistakes; from mistakes comes experimentation, from experimentation comes personal agency, and from agency grows artistic independence. 

My late mentor Christine Brown was an extraordinary example of an educator who mastered this balance. In her lessons, she made me feel completely nurtured, yet she could tell me with absolute clarity what I needed to do for technical and musical success. She built a profound self-belief in me, once squeezing my hand and saying,

“Your pupils are lucky to have you as a teacher.”

That exact feeling of being valued and believed in is what we must pass on. 

Children who experience stress elsewhere often feel a lack of control. We can foster agency on the piano stool by inviting students to become co-authors of their musical journey.

Giving them small choices, such as deciding whether to start with a technical warm-up or helping select their next piece, can be empowering. Providing a balance of core repertoire alongside “music in the moment” (such as pop arrangements or film classics) keeps enthusiasm alive.

Crucially, creating a supportive environment does not mean blurring professional lines. Many anxious children benefit from clear, unwavering boundaries. Knowing exactly what is expected provides an essential framework of confidence. 

We must always remember that we are music educators, not therapists. When a child shares vulnerable personal disclosures, it is our professional responsibility to maintain robust safeguarding boundaries through up-to-date training with bodies like the Musicians’ Union (MU) or the NSPCC. Combining genuine warmth with clear, professional boundaries protects both pupil and teacher. 

The impact of our teaching stretches well beyond the pages of a method book or an exam syllabus.

A few years ago, a five-year-old pupil left a decorated envelope for me. Inside were three notes explaining how much she loved coming to lessons because she was always greeted with a big smile. It was a humbling reminder of how deeply children absorb our presence.

When long-term students eventually move on, I have a tradition of gifting them a small personal painting of a place that holds meaning for them. It is my way of saying thank you, letting them know I see them not just as music students, but as wonderful human beings going out into the world.

The piano stool can be one of a number of launching pads from which they venture out, take risks, discover their voice, and leave us with confidence. 

By showing up each week with warmth, predictability, and professional regard, we have the immense privilege of nurturing those qualities, one lesson, one shared musical experience, and one welcoming smile at a time.


  • Marshall, K. (2024). Music and Neurodiversity: A Practical Guide for Music Educators. London: Collins Music.
  • Obsuth, I., et al. (2017). The long-term effects of positive teacher-student relationships on adolescent behaviour. European Journal of Developmental Psychology, 14(4), 442–458.
  • Musicians’ Union (MU) & NSPCC: Safeguarding and Child Protection Resources for Music Educators. 
  • Department for Education (2020): Special Educational Needs and Disability (SEND) Code of Practice: 0 to 25 Years. 

Karen Marshall is an experienced music educator, author, and neurodiversity specialist with over three decades of classroom, instrumental, and private piano teaching experience. Having recently completed secondary school teacher training, she has written over 30 publications, focusing on making music education accessible to all learners.



Pianodao offers over 700 articles and reviews, all FREE to access.
If you appreciate this content, please support and follow the site:



Published by

Andrew Eales

Andrew Eales is a widely respected piano educator based in Milton Keynes UK. His many publications include 'How to Practise Music' (Hal Leonard, 2021).