Products featured on Pianodao are selected for review by ANDREW EALES.
PIANODAO REVIEWS POLICY
As many will know, pianists and classical music lovers are this year marking the centenary of Debussy’s death in 1918.
In a previous post I addressed the frequently asked question, “where to start?” exploring his piano works, suggesting Bärenreiter Edition’s Easy Pieces and Dances collection and their excellent urtext edition of the Preludes livre 1 as great entry points.
In this post I will look at a couple of Bärenreiter’s other Debussy editions – the two volumes of Images, but first Pour le piano. These are virtuoso concert works which qualify for the diploma and professional tag in terms of difficulty.
Pour le piano
Though the central piece of this three-movement work, the Sarabande, dates from 1894, Pour le piano was only completed and published in 1901. It is often regarded as a watershed in Debussy’s compositional development, with enough formal gestures of the past to place it at the end of his first phase – which included such gems as the Deux Arabesques (1888), Reverie (1890) and Suite Bergamasque (also 1890) – but with strong hints of the more searching, experimental music of his mature style.
The opening Prélude is a showpiece of sparkling effervescence from its first notes, which build to a stunning climax in which glissandi contrast ecstatic and sonorous chordal motives. The Satie-influenced Sarabande is as expected a more solemn affair, but is imbued with the lightness of touch that is such a gorgeous feature of Debussy’s earlier works. The closing Toccata is the most challenging of the three movements, a piece which concludes this tremendous concert work with towering pianistic bravura and ends in a blaze of triumphant affirmation.
Bärenreiter’s urtext edition introduces itself as “The Authoritative Performing Edition” – a claim I feel it comfortably lives up to.
Edited by Regina Back, and with fingering by Frederik Palme, this beautifully produced publication includes a detailed introduction with sections covering the genesis and publication history of Pour le piano, detailed ideas on its aesthetics and suggestions for performance practice (with subsections on pedalling, tempo and phrasing, fingering, articulation and expression, and dynamics), scholarly notes on the edition itself, a list of the sources, and translations of all Debussy’s performing instructions.
There is also a facsimile of the autograph manuscript.
With such abundant and brilliantly written content, it is little surprise that the music itself only appears once we reach the staples in the middle of the book!
While the score itself can be described as a critical scholarly edition, drawing on all the known sources, and including detailed critical commentary, it is no less a fabulous performance edition, with crystal clear notation printed on cream paper, generously spaced as in this authorised sample from the opening of the Prelude:
It is “authoritative” indeed!
Images 1 & 2
If Debussy’s mature style is plain to hear in Pour le piano, it has exploded into full bloom by the time we reach Images 1st Series (1903-5) and Images 2nd Series (1907). Writing to his publisher Jacques Durand about the first series in August 1905, the composer enthused:
“I believe – without unwarranted vanity – that these three pieces will prove to be good and that they will take a prominent place in the literature of piano music … to the left of Schumann or to the right of Chopin … as you like it.”
Upon the publication of Douglas Woodfull-Harris’s urtext version in 2012, Bärenreiter wrote:
“In commemoration of Debussy’s 150th birthday, Bärenreiter is publishing an Urtext edition of these pieces reflecting the most recent scholarship and source analysis. Clear presentation, fingering by Tamara Stefanovich and valuable information on performance practice all offer optimal conditions for the study of the work.”
Images 1re série
• Reflets dans l’eau
• Hommage à Rameau
Images 2e série
• Cloches à travers les feuilles
• Et la lune descend sur le temple qui fut
• Poissons d’or
Like Pour le piano before it, each of the two sets of Images are structured in three movements which follow classical precedents.
Reflets dans l’eau opens Images 1, and is deservedly one of the composer’s best-loved pieces, a picturesque masterpiece of tonal colour, harmonic alchemy and technical control. Hommage à Rameau meanwhile recalls the Sarabande from Pour le piano, and is once again a stately dance in three-time. Here, hints of Satie as precursor are perhaps overshadowed by the lyrical expressivity and ripe chromaticism of the lush harmonies. The final Mouvement is – following a similar trajectory to Pour le piano – another dazzling toccata, generating an incredible sensation of animated motion before speeding away into the distance.
Still more evocative – and surely deserving of the term “impressionism”, whether Debussy approved or not – the pieces of Images 2 are a tour de force which bursts to the top end of the piano repertoire in difficulty as well as in quality.
For clarity – textural as well as textual – these three pieces are written across three staves throughout, as in this example:
Bärenreiter predictably bring presentational excellence mixed with definitive scholarship to their editions (in two volumes) of Images.
The brilliant Preface covers much the same ground as that for Pour le piano, albeit written by a different editor. A comparison between the two is instructive, but suffice to say that each is excellent. Here again we are treated to a highly readable and informative introduction to the genesis of the works, their aesthetics, performance practice and notes on the edition.
In her “Note on Fingering”, Tamara Stefanovich reminds us that Debussy himself found fingering undesirable, declaring “Cherchons nos doigtés!” (let us find our own fingerings!), while herself arguing for the value of proposing fingerings which “are meant to provide an opportunity to shape a performance”. Today’s pianists, playing on instruments with a heavier touch and less rich in overtones, will undoubtedly welcome Tamara’s helpful suggestions and find them a useful addition to this fabulous edition of Debussy’s evocative masterpiece.
Suffice to conclude, then, that as with Pour le piano, Bärenreiter have again raised the bar and produced a winning critical urtext edition of Images 1 and 2.
THANK YOU FOR VISITING
Pianodao features more than 600 FREE articles and reviews, offering expert insight to equip, inform and inspire piano players and teachers everywhere.
The site takes many hours each month to research, write, and maintain. If you would like to show your appreciation and support, PLEASE DONATE HERE.
RECEIVE NOTIFICATIONS of fresh content by adding your email here: